Alerting Houses of Worship to the Dangers of Partisan Politicking

Posted by Beth on September 19, 2006

On Monday, Americans United for Separation of Church and State announced a national campaign to inform houses of worship about federal tax law forbidding partisan politicking by tax-exempt groups.

The watchdog group said it will mail a special election-year alert to all houses of worship in 11 states, reminding them that intervention in partisan political campaigns is a violation of the Internal Revenue Service Code.

More than 117,000 letters were sent to every house of worship in Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Montana, New Jersey, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Texas, Missouri and Virginia.

Those states were selected, because they are being targeted by James Dobson and other Religious Right leaders who want to build a church-based political machine on behalf of favored Republican candidates.

"Dragging churches into partisan politics is just plain wrong," said the Rev. Barry W. Lynn, Americans United executive director. "It violates tax law, it damages the integrity of religion and it harms our democracy.

"Dobson and other Religious Right leaders want to politicize America’s pulpits," Lynn continued. "I urge religious leaders not to go along with it. Houses of worship that get drawn into Dobson’s political machine could emerge with their tax-exempt status severely mangled."

In August, Religious Right leader Dobson’s Focus on the Family (FOF) appealed to supporters in eight states to mobilize evangelical Christian churches before the November elections. The e-mail said the group’s state affiliates will lead the project and asked for volunteers to serve as county coordinators and church coordinators. Pastors will be asked to give political sermons, and churches will be encouraged to hand out voter guides.

The Dobson effort focuses on states with hotly contested congressional and gubernatorial races. The FOF e-mail said, "In 2004, about 25 million evangelicals failed to vote. Now is the time to reverse the trend."

Lynn, who is a United Church of Christ minister, warned pastors to be wary of the FOF overture. He noted that Dobson is increasingly acting as a Republican political operative. Dobson communicates regularly with GOP congressional leaders and White House staff, he endorses GOP candidates and he takes credit for the defeat of former U.S. Sen. Tom Daschle (D-S.D.).

Lynn said religious leaders need to be especially wary of the voter guides that will be produced by FOF affiliates, since the IRS has warned churches about distributing voter guides produced by outside groups. Lynn said the FOF guides are almost certain to be partisan material that seeks to portray Dobson’s preferred candidates in a favorable light while disparaging their opponents.

"Biased voter guides have no place in houses of worship, period," Lynn said.

In clear cases of violations of federal tax law, Lynn said, Americans United will not hesitate to ask the IRS to intervene.

AU’s mailing to counter the Dobson effort includes all of his targeted states (Pennsylvania, Maryland, Michigan, Ohio, New Jersey, Minnesota, Montana and Tennessee) and adds three others (Texas, Virginia and Missouri) that have shown evidence of church-based political organizing.

Lynn noted that the IRS is paying special attention to violations of the tax code by non-profit groups this year. The agency has formed a "Political Activity Compliance Initiative" and has vowed to respond swiftly to violations.

In public speeches, IRS Commissioner Mark Everson has said that the very integrity of tax-exempt entities is at stake. His comments followed a report by the tax agency showing that many of the non-profits being investigated for violations during the last election cycle are churches.

In addition to the mass mailing to churches, AU’s Web site (www.au.org) will feature updated materials on church-based politicking prepared by Marcus Owens of the Washington, D.C., firm of Caplin & Drysdale. Owens is the former director of the Exempt Organizations Division of the IRS.

AU’s 75,000 members nationwide will also be given a copy of the letter to religious leaders and asked to copy and mail it to houses of worship in their community. Thus, the effort will reach religious leaders in all 50 states.

First Freedom First is a project of Americans United for Separation of Church and State, and The Interfaith Alliance Foundation. One of the issues of concern to the First Freedom First campaign is church politicking. Our petition says: "Political candidates should not be endorsed or opposed by houses of worship." If you have not yet signed the petition, please do so today!

Beth Corbin – First Freedom First Project Director-AU

Madison Wisconsin Catholic Church

Submitted by drunde on Thu, 2006-11-02 17:49.

Bishop Morlino of the Madison, Wisconsin Diocese has mandated that all Catholic Churches in the Diocese play a recording of the Bishop's plea for catholics to vote in favor of a change in the Wisconsin constitution making "same sex marriages" illegal. This is up for vote in this coming Tuesday's election. Is this not considered "lobbying" and against the IRS rules that govern tax exempt entities from engaging in such activity?
Thank you, Denise Runde

login or register to post comments

Issue advocacy

Submitted by Beth on Fri, 2006-11-03 02:52.

Denise, thank you for visiting the First Freedom First web site, and for your support. IRS rules allow a house of worship to engage in issue advocacy. Their tax exempt status is only in jeopardy if they endorse or oppose a specific candidate or political party.

For more information on this I encourage you to visit the Project Fair Play web site.

You can also check out what First Freedom First has to say on the issue by going to our web page on Respect For All Families.

Thank you again for your question, and please take some time between now and the election to encourage your friends to sign our petition.

Beth Corbin
First Freedom First Director - AU

login or register to post comments

The Jefferson Society